American Playhouse – A Matter of Principle

A Matter of Principe is TV episode of American Playhouse, an American anthology series which aired from 1982 through till 1996 on the PBS channel.

Spanning a total of 13 Seasons and 176 episodes, American Playhouse has had some properly good talent go through its doors. The likes of Kenneth Branagh, Jeff Daniels, Ed Harris, Raul Julia, Jason Robards and Susan Sarandon have all had their parts to play in the American Playhouse legend.

“A Matter of Principal” is an episode from the show’s fourth season, the second episode of that season in fact. It of course features Virginia Madsen starring alongside Alan Arkin and his real life wife, Barbara Dana. It’s the story of a poor family who worry that Santa won’t visit them if they don’t have a tree due to their Dads refusal.

The episode was shown on the 3rd of December so although it was a bit early by my standard it was one to show with a Christmas theme.

Now. I’m a grumpy old “Bah humbug” type of guy, “Christmas Films” aren’t my thing. At all. Not even a little one. Well, I guess “Violent Night”, that’s a good Christmas Film. If you’re about to say “But what about Die Hard?” then you can get off my site now, and never ever come back.

Can the appearance of Virginia Madsen change all of that and have me looking fondly on a yuletide film?Virginia Madsen in A Matter of Principle (1984), walking down a small-town street with a young man. She wears a brown coat and a dark hat, her long hair cascading over her shoulders. The slightly grainy image captures a vintage atmosphere, with storefronts, a reflection of a courthouse dome in the window, and a parked car in the background.No. No she can not.

I mean, to be fair – I’ve seen worse.

We’re introduced to the Purdy family via Flag Purdy (Alan Arkin) is in the bank disputing the fact that he’s paid his bill but is informed he’s not paid the tax. He claims he didn’t vote for the tax and so he shouldn’t have to pay it. Straight away we know who has the principles in this one then.

Flag returns home to his family and we soon find out there are more than a couple of them living under the one roof. Flag and his wife Ada (Barbara Dana) have been blessed with an ungodly amount of children, and that’s including a newborn. The eldest, Lou Ellen (Virginia) helps out around the house but she’s far from impressed with her Dad’s penny pinching ways.

Virginia Madsen in A Matter of Principle (1984), sitting at a table in a modest home, wearing a light-colored coat. She appears to be in conversation with a woman across from her, who is dressed in a dark coat. A man in a plaid jacket stands in the doorway, looking concerned. The dim lighting and simple decor emphasize the film’s small-town, working-class setting.Flag is doing his best not to spend any money that he doesn’t have to do. No heating in the house, when his wife hints at an electric blanket he offers to lie on her side of the bed to warm it up, and then of course there is the crux of the movie, the Christmas tree. He claims he doesn’t want a tree in the house because if The Good Lord wanted trees in the house then he would have planted them there” and it’s just “contrary to nature”.

The family are determined to have a Christmas this year and they work against him to bring some festive cheer to the house. Lou Ellen along with her fiance buy the house a tree which leaves Flag less than impressed culminating in a stand up row between him and the family when he catches them celebrating.

Slowly the family get more and more disillusioned with Flag and begin to ignore his wishes, much to his chagrin.

I won’t go into more detail, it’s a short “film” at just under an hour long. But, well it’s a Christmas film so I’m sure it won’t take a lot of your brain power to work out how the rest of it goes, especially if you are familiar with the tale of Scrooge.Virginia Madsen in A Matter of Principle (1984), sitting at a dinner table with a serious expression. She wears a brown coat, and her long hair is pulled back. Beside her, a woman in a knitted vest and collared shirt looks on attentively. The simple setting, with plates of food and glasses on the table, emphasizes the film’s small-town, working-class atmosphere.Considering it’s an early outing for Virginia Madsen in her career she gets quite a pivotal role in this one, you can tell she’s pretty much still learning the ropes but she manages to impress among the cast.

Availability:
Adding this to your physical media collection isn’t that easy at the moment. It saw a release on DVD in the US but beyond that I’m not sure and the details are sketchy. I snagged a copy of it a LONG time ago, before I even knew what it was and back when it was just listed on iMBD as “A Matter of Principal” with no mention of “American Playhouse”. I don’t remember it being particularly hard to find at the time, but obviously these things change.

If you’re looking for a copy on DVD to call your own then I’d suggest using “A Matter of Principal”, “American Playhouse: A Matter of Principal” or even just “American Playhouse” to try and get there. Maybe add “DVD” to the end of your search.

Digitally, is another matter and one you might have to settle for until a random copy appears on eBay, or even Amazon.

Gallery:

« Back to Gallery Selection

A Matter of Principle - Production Stills

<    Previous Home Next     >

Related:

Title card for Class (1983), featuring bold yellow text over an industrial parking lot with a white van and an orange sports car. The background includes a factory with smokestacks, setting the tone for the film’s contrast between working-class and elite prep school life.Class Title card for Fire with Fire (1986). The film’s title appears in white serif text against a lush forest backdrop. In the distance, a young woman with curly blonde hair (Virginia Madsen) is seen running away through the woods, wearing a light blue top and red pants, adding a sense of urgency and adventure to the sceneFire with Fire virginia madsen in mr northMr. North virginia madsen in zombie highZombie High